The IRS's political agenda isn't just about the Tea Party
In the ongoing imbroglio over the Internal Revenue Service, it's the IRS's treatment of the Tea Party that has grabbed most of the headlines. But I have shown in the past, as have others, that the IRS also discriminated against organizations that opposed President Hussein Obama's Middle East policies. The most blatant case where that happened was the denial of tax exempt status to Z Street, an organization based in Philadelphia that seeks to help Jews in Judea and Samaria. The IRS claims that conservative organizations like Z Street
were 'stuck' in the bureaucracy, and that's why their applications took so long to process. But the Wall Street Journal reports this morning that emails from the IRS
(at least those that were not erased) show that the dragged out process that Z Street (specifically) faced was deliberate
2009 the Pennsylvania group Z Street applied for tax-exempt status for
its mission of educating people about Israel-related issues. In 2010 an
IRS agent told Z Street that its application was delayed because the tax
agency's Washington, D.C. office was giving special scrutiny to groups
whose missions might conflict with Administration policies. The IRS's
"Be On the Lookout" list that November also included red flags for
groups referring to "disputed territories."
Street sued in August 2010 for viewpoint discrimination and its case is
headed for discovery in federal court. Now emails uncovered by the
House Ways and Means Committee show that the IRS and State Department
were conferring in 2009 about pro-Israel groups like Z Street and
considering arguments to deny their tax-exempt applications.
an April 16, 2009 email, Treasury attache to the U.S. Embassy in
Jerusalem Katherine Bauer sent IRS and Treasury colleagues a 1997 JTA
News article sent to her by State Department foreign service officer
Breeann McCusker. The subject was whether 501(c) groups buying land in
Israel's disputed territories were engaged in "possible violations of
U.S. tax laws." The article chronicles the controversy and whether
"ideological activity" can "legally be financed with the help of U.S.
you might find the below article of interest—looks like we've been down
this road before," Ms. Bauer wrote. "Although I believe you've said you
can't speak to on-going investigations, I thought it was worth flagging
the 1997 investigation mentioned below for you if it can be of any use
internally when looking for precedence [sic] for the current cases." A
Treasury spokesman declined comment on Ms. Bauer's behalf.
"current cases" would have been applications like Z Street's in which
Israel-related activity was apparently being scrutinized for its
ideological and policy content. The government says Z Street got special
scrutiny because it was focused in a region with a higher risk of
terrorism, which is hard to believe and in any case doesn't explain all
of the IRS's behavior.
doesn't cover, for instance, why one questionnaire we've seen from the
IRS to another Jewish group applying for tax-exempt status asked, "Does
your organization support the existence of the land of Israel?" and
"Describe your organization's religious belief system toward the land of
Israel." No matter the answers, they should not affect the processing
of an application for 501(c) status. The State-IRS emails reveal a
political motivation for IRS scrutiny that gives Z Street powerful
evidence for its suit charging IRS bias.
the IRS filed an appeal of the judge's decision denying its motion to
dismiss Z Street's case. The government says the action stops all
discovery while the appeal is pending, a process that could take months
or even years. By filing the appeal on the last possible day, the
Justice Department is running out the clock on discovery during the
remainder of the Administration.
It's a pity that by the time this case is decided, it may no longer be possible to sanction the Obama administration. If I were representing Z Street, I would do everything I could to expedite a decision.
Labels: Barack Hussein Obama, Internal Revenue Service, Z Street