Powered by WebAds

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Are boycotts ever right?

In the wake of the heckling of Michael Oren at the University of California at Irvine, a dispute has broken out between the Zionist Organization of America and the Anti-Defamation League over whether a boycott of UC Irvine by the Jewish community is justified. Jonathan Tobin weighs in.
But no matter whether you think further efforts to improve the situation at UC Irvine are warranted or not, the ADL’s belief that boycotts are inherently wrong cannot be sustained. It is true that in our own time anti-Israel and anti-Semitic elements have attempted to create boycotts of Israeli academics and produce and that the Jewish community has rightly decried such despicable campaigns. But these boycotts are wrong not because a desire to isolate any movement or country is inherently evil but rather because it is unjust to apply such measures to a democratic state besieged by terrorists who wish to destroy. In the past, Jews have readily embraced boycotts. Jewish activists once boycotted the Soviet Union and protested any commerce or diplomatic niceties conducted with an anti-Semitic Communist government, which had refused to let Russian Jews immigrate to freedom in Israel or the United States. Jews also boycotted Germany during the 1930s as the Nazis set the stage for the Holocaust. There is also the fact that the vast majority of American Jews were profoundly sympathetic to boycotts of grapes picked by non-union labor as well as those aimed at isolating apartheid-era South Africa. The idea that one cannot boycott evildoers just because leftist extremists wish to wrongly use the same tactic on Israel makes no sense.
Indeed. The only principle that's absolute is that nothing is absolute.

2 Comments:

At 11:14 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

time for Abe to retire.

 
At 6:56 PM, Blogger Unknown said...

Boycotts may or may not be right, but if I had a child applying to college this year, UC Irvine would not be on his list.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

Google