What happens when someone hangs a 'Palestinian' flag in anti-Zionist Meah Shearim?
What happens when someone (rumored to be the head of Neturei Karta) hangs a 'Palestinian' flag in the anti-Zionist (Jerusalem) neighborhood of Meah Shearim?
You might be surprised.
Let's go to the videotape.
Give that guy a medal - he scaled the side of a two-story building to take that flag down.
Leader of Iranian green movement won't even shake hands with a Jew
Some of you might recall that in 2009, I kept asking all the Iranian greens I was following where they stood on Israel. If they weren't open to having diplomatic relations with us, I would ignore them. A curse on both their houses. I couldn't get a straight answer. I kept getting told it's not relevant now.
Now, I know for sure why I got that answer. Here's an English translation of the caption of the picture above.
“This is Iran’s deceased Ayatollah Montazeri (d. December, 2009) in the photograph where he rejected shaking the hand of a fellow Jewish Iranian. He declined the handshake because he did not want to become dirty (najis) and his cleanliness despoiled for his “Salaat” preparation (for prayer, as a Muslim), by contacting the (najis, infidel) Jew.” (thanks to S for the translation)
So yes, Ahmadinejad kissed the Neturei Karta nutjobs who showed up for his Holocaust denial conference. But they're a different kind of Jew.
Both Roger Cohen and the Neturei Karta should be pleased. Iranian Jews came out on Tuesday to denounce Zionism and to demonstrate in favor of their country's pursuit of nuclear weapons. I'm sure they were (not) all there voluntarily....
Demonstrators held the Torah and banners with statements in English,
Hebrew and Farsi in support of Iran's nuclear negotiators, and performed
mass religious ceremonies, Iranian PressTV reported.
"Iranian monotheists are proud of supreme leader fatwa for prohibition of mass killing weapons," the banners read.
“We,
the Iranian Jews, announce our full support for Iran’s negotiating team
in the talks with the P5+1 and advise the other party to seize this
opportunity,” a statement issued by the Jewish community in Iran read.
The
statement added that the Iranian Jews "insist on standing by their
Muslim brothers in defending the right to use peaceful nuclear energy
for scientific and economic progress of Iran."
The statement also included a denouncement of Zionism, saying that it "has nothing to do with Judaism."
Isn't it amazing that they're free to demonstrate in Iran? (If you believe that, you are a useful idiot)
Video: Canadian 'Palestinian' leader tells Jews to leave Israel or die, Neturei Karta has no objections
In an earlier post, I reported on the al-Quds day rally in Toronto at which a Canadian 'Palestinian' leader told Israelis to leave Israel and Jerusalem or be shot.
I now have a brief video of that incident (which includes a two-minute warning for us to leave).
Let's go to the videotape.
I guess the Neturei Karta guys (from 0:38 to 0:57 of the video) didn't find his words objectionable. I wonder what makes them think he'd treat them any differently. Their hatred is truly blind.
It's been a long day working, but it sure beats the alternatives....
An Israeli member of the anti-Zionist Neturei Karta cult has been charged with spying for Iran.
There had previously been a media blackout on the case and a gag order remains on the haredi man’s identity.
At
an unknown date, the man, 47, decided to make contact with the Iranian
government in order to collect intelligence on Israel and send it to
them, the indictment alleged.
In order to do this, he went online to check where he could approach an Iranian embassy, said the indictment.
The
indictment said that in January 2011, he flew to Berlin and two days
after arriving, approached the embassy to tell the Iranians that he was
an Israeli and wanted to speak to them.
At the time he was clothed in
his regular haredi dresswear, including black and white clothes, and
tzizit (ritual undergarments).
Next, he met Hagi Baba and two others, said the indictment.
According
to the indictment, he told Baba that he was against the Jewish state,
wanted the state to be taken over by non-jews, was ready to provide them
intelligence and was even ready to "kill a Zionist," if necessary.
And you though Haredim don't use the internet....
If someone has an argument why - assuming this story turns out to be true - the spy is not a moser (someone who turns a fellow Jew over to be killed) under Shulchan Aruch Choshen Mishpat 388 (the name of a book and the chapter in the book), I'm all ears.
It's only natural for a President in his last days in office to look back nostalgically on the 'successes' of his administration (Hat Tip: Hot Air via Shy Guy).
Outgoing Iranian
President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad on Sunday described his denial of the
Holocaust as one of his greatest achievements, the Fars news agency
reported.
"That
was a taboo topic that no one in the West allowed to be heard,"
Ahmadinejad said in a speech looking back at his time in office. He had
enough courage to bring up the issue, he said.
"That broke the spine of the Western capitalist regime," he claimed.
I can't wait to hear what President Hussein Obama claims as his greatest achievement. Perhaps breaking the spine of the Western capitalist regime?
Israel's first political assassination was not the murder of Yitzchak Rabin in 1995, nor was it the murder of British Count Bernadot by the Irgun in the 1940's. Israel's first political assassination was 89 years ago yesterday - June 30, 1924 - and it was carried out by the Hagana, the force that eventually became the IDF. The victim was a Dutch poet, journalist and legal scholar named Jacob Israel de Haan, and he was murdered because he was an anti-Zionist.
Let's go to the videotape.
Initially, de Haan was involved with Zionist circles in his new home. He
helped establish the Jerusalem Law Classes in 1919, where he lectured,
worked as a correspondent for a Dutch newspaper, and continued writing
poetry. Soon, he met and found a kindred spirit in Rabbi Yosef Chaim
Sonnenfeld, the founder of the ultra-Orthodox, anti-Zionist Edah Haredit
community, and became his political spokesman. He also is said to have
taken an interest in the young boys of Jerusalem, both Jewish and Arab.
Within a short time, de Haan became critical of the secular nature of
the Zionist movement and of its relationship with the Orthodox
community. He also became convinced that it was on a collision course
with the indigenous Arab population of the land.
In
1922, the same year that Jacob de Haan defended Agudath Israel, the
Haredi political movement, in a legal trial over its refusal to pay a
new excise tax levied by Zionist authorities on matzot before Passover,
he also met with Lord Northcliffe, founder of the Daily Mail newspaper
in London, when the latter visited the region. He shared his
anti-Zionist views with Northcliffe and those views were reported back
in the United Kingdom. Soon, de Haan was offered work as a correspondent
for the tabloid Daily Express. De Haan also met with Hashemite leader
Hussein bin Ali, the King of Hejaz, to discuss the establishment of a
Palestinian state.
By
now, de Haan had become a liability to the Zionist movement, and
especially dangerous because of the platform he now had for spreading
his views in London, where critical decisions about Palestine were
made. In Jerusalem, he became persona non grata among Zionists,
including his law students. One anecdote has him walking with a Dutch
visitor, who observed that as people passed them into the street, they
were spitting on the sidewalk. The visitor thought this was a sign of
disrespect, to which de Haan responded, according to Dutch historian
Ludy Giebels: “"Oh no, they spit on the street out of respect for you,
your presence. Otherwise they would have spit in my face."
Early
on the morning of June 30, 1924, as he left the synagogue in Shaare
Zedek hospital, on Jaffa Road, de Haan was shot three times. He died
immediately.
The
British authorities offered a reward for information that would lead to
his killer, but no one was ever tried for the crime. The killing was
thought to have been ordered by the Haganah, but it was only in the
1980s that two Israeli journalists, Shlomo Nakdimon and Shaul Mayzlish,
received an admission of guilt from Israeli businessman Avraham Tehomi,
who was then living in Hong Kong.
Tehomi
told the journalists that he had been acting on orders of the Haganah,
specifically of Yitzhak Ben-Zvi, an officer in the militia and a
political activist, later the second president of the State of Israel:
"I have done what the Haganah decided had to be done. And nothing was
done without the order of Yitzhak Ben-Zvi ... I have no regrets because he [de Haan] wanted to destroy our whole idea of Zionism."
Although Neturei Karta are considered very much a fringe group even among Haredim today, the influence of the de Haan assassination continues. More here.
Europeans like to distinguish between being anti-Jewish and
anti-Zionist. Neturei Karta is an anti-Zionist branch of Judaism so
opposed to the state of Israel that they’ve met with President
Ahmadinejad, presumably to hear his exciting plans for wiping it off the
map. Unfortunately, back in the Netherlands, this Neturei Karta rabbi’s
assailant didn’t get the memo.
...
“B-but I’m not that kind of Jew” doesn’t get you as far on the streets of Europe as it does in the presidential palace in Iran.
He eventually moved to Antwerp where (assuming that the news reports are correct) he has done something that ought to turn him into a moser (link in Hebrew) in the eyes of the Jewish community (leaving aside for a minute that he defied the ban contained in Shulchan Aruch Choshen Mishpat 26 against availing oneself of the secular courts against fellow Jews). Moshe Aryeh Friedman filed and won a lawsuit against a private Jewish girls' school in Antwerp forcing them to admit his sons to study there. The school is now facing fines of $2,600 per child per day if it does not comply (Hat Tip: Mrs. Carl).
At the end of 2011, Friedman relocated his wife and seven children from New York to Antwerp, but because of what Friedman calls “revenge” on the part of the Jewish community for his “opinion and good contacts with world leaders”, he has been unable to find a yeshiva which will admit his children. As such, Friedman said he had no choice but to apply for admission for his sons, ages 8 and 11, to the all-girls, Orthodox Jewish Benoth Jerusalem School in Antwerp.
According to a report in the local Belgian paper, Gazet van Anwerpen (http://bit.ly/VblYff), when Benoth Jerusalem denied admission to his sons, Friedman sued citing a recent decision from the Commission on Students’ Rights which held that a child cannot be denied admission to a school on the basis of their gender.
A Belgian judge ruled that because yeshivas are subsidized by the Flemish community, Benoth Jerusalem must admit the boys or face a $2,600 penalty per child for each day the boys are not permitted to attend.
The school board argued that Orthodox Judaism requires the separation of the sexes for educational instruction. Moreover, the board said it is not equipped to educate male students as it does not have male teachers on staff and lacks basic infrastructure such as separate restrooms.
The school board has until next week to appeal the judge’s ruling.
If this story is true, Friedman has assured his and his family's ostracism from the ultra-Orthodox Jewish community for life (at least unless and until his children are old enough to denounce him).
For generations, Orthodox Jews have hired private teachers to educate their children at home if they could not find an appropriate school. That's what Friedman should have done if no school would accept his children. And if he could not find anyone to teach them (because he is probably in cherem - excommunicated - so no one will deal with him) he should teach them himself. If he has to send them to a school, let him either recant and have the cherem released, or let him send them to public schools until he does so.
Second, I mentioned the prohibition in Shulchan Aruch Choshen Mishpat 26 against turning to secular courts against fellow Jews (link in Hebrew).
Third, for anyone who believes that all ultra-Orthodox Jews support Neturei Karta, this should convince you otherwise. As I understand it, both the school in Vienna that expelled his children six years ago, and the school in Antwerp are operated by mainstream ultra-Orthodox communities.
And fourth, Friedman should have thought about this before embracing a Jew-hater like Ahmadinejad. Actions have consequences. No, I have zero sympathy for this guy. Look at the picture at the top to see why.
Finally, Babylonian Jewry was riven by internal disputes between its
religious and temporal leaders. Disputes, especially disputes that touch
on religious matters invariably lead to extremist views and
unacceptable behavior – all under the guise of following the will of
Heaven.
There is much extremism under display in American Jewry
today. Ah, but you will counter, how about the extremism in the
religious circles in Israel. But there is a fundamental difference
between Israel and America. Here in Israel the extremism is mostly
political in nature - the quest for patronage and budget allocations,
and the personal ambitions of politicians for office and power.
With
all of the trappings of piety surrounding them, the contests here are
basically much more personal than ideological. The anti-Israel groupings
in Israel have waned in numbers and influence while, unfortunately,
they have increased in the American Jewish society. More and more, the
hareidi society in Israel sees itself as part of the general apparatus
of the state, and the nineteenth century battle over Zionism has ended
here. It is a moot question.
Not so in American Jewish society
where actual hatred of the State of Israel exists in many sections of
that society, from the intellectual Left to the extremists in the
religious world on the Right.
When Babylonia saw itself as the substitute for Jerusalem as a safe haven for all eternity, its decline immediately set in.
Truly revolting video of Ahmadinejad meeting with Neturei Karta in New York
This video is sickening and I'm sorry that it may ruin a lot of your holidays. It's a video of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad meeting with representatives of Neturei Karta in New York. Simply disgusting.
Let's go to the videotape (Hat Tip: Will).
There's so much wrong with this video and what he's saying, that I cannot begin to explain it to those who aren't well versed in Talmudic study (particularly Kethuboth 110-111). But what he's doing is endangering millions of Jews in Israel and elsewhere, and that is totally forbidden.
None of the other Jewish anti-Zionist groups (Satmar and Munkatch come to mind) would have pulled a stunt like this. Simply beyond belief.
The difference between a Jewish anti-Zionist and a non-Jewish anti-Zionist
Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld was the founder of the Eida Charedis, which is one of the centers of anti-Zionist activism in the Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) community to this day (NOTE - Most Haredim are NOT Neturei Karta and that includes the Eida).
He was a student of Rabbi Samuel Benjamin Sofer (the Ksav Sofer), the son of Rabbi Moses Sofer (the Chasam Sofer). He was also a student of Rabbi Avraham Schag in Kobersdorf (who was himself a disciple of the Chasam Sofer); Sonnenfeld moved from the latter city to Jerusalem in 1873.
He became an important figure in Jerusalem's Old City, serving as the right-hand man of Rabbi Yehoshua Leib Diskin and assisting the latter in communal activities, such as the founding of schools and the Diskin Orphanage, and the fight against secularism. He refused to meet with Kaiser Wilhelm of Germany who visited the Old City because he believed that the Emperor was a descendant of the nation of Amalek. Sonnenfeld sent a delegate, a former Dutch diplomat and writer who had become a baal teshuva, Dr. Jacob Israël de Haan, to Jordan with a peace proposal for King Abdullah.
Contrary to a number of distorted accounts, he had a warm relationship with and mutual respect for Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook, although the two were vigorous opponents in many areas. Indeed, in 1913 the two traveled together to Northern Israel to try to return lapsed Jews to Torah Judaism.
Rabbi Benny Lau (the son of former Chief Rabbi Yisrael Meir Lau) is on the noontime news magazine on Israel Radio every Friday (usually I am in the car then and cannot share his wisdom with you), and just told the following story about Rav Sonnenfeld:
The Mufti, Haj al-Amin al-Husseini (Arafat's uncle) visited Rav Sonnenfeld, and said, "You are anti-Zionists and we are anti-Zionists. Why don't we work together?"
Rav Sonnenfeld's response: "We cannot work together. We hate what is goyish (non-Jewish) about the Zionists, while you hate what is Jewish about them."
I think that's a great story that goes a long way toward explaining the sometimes conflicted feelings that much of the Haredi community (of which Rav Kook was also a part - his philosophy is widely admired in the National Religious community today) has toward the state.
I reported last week that one Kenneth Insley, who billed himself as a representative of the State Department, was present at the Doha Conference to 'save' Jerusalem. Now that we see what Mr. Insley had to say, perhaps Secretary of State Clinton can find the time to repudiate him. In fact, perhaps Prime Minister Netanyahu should raise the issue with President Obama this week as a test of Obama's bona fides in being pro-Israel.
Insley bills himself as a consultant to the U.S. government. His day job is director of public diplomacy at Capital Communications Group, an international consulting firm that has apparently gotten a government contract for coordinating visits for international delegations with various think tanks, congressional leaders, White House and other administration officials. But his main business seems to be promoting anti-Israel hatred. While ignoring Israel’s peace offers and Palestinian rejectionism and terror, Insley did not shy away from pandering to his audience’s appetite for slurs against Israel. After defending Jimmy Carter’s claim that Israel is an apartheid state, he denounced the efforts of some Jewish religious figures to urge people to marry within their faith:
Play this game with me: if you were to substitute the word “white” for “Jewish” and replace the word “Arab men” with “NIGGER,” then to most American ears, it sounds exactly like the pronouncements of racist segregationists in the 1950s and 60s in southern states like Georgia, which where Jimmy Carter is from. I think President Carter knows a thing or two about racial discrimination. And so should the Jewish people. … Perhaps it is understandable to be perceived as racist when you are considered by some to be “God’s chosen people.”
It may well be that Insley’s participation in this hate fest had nothing to do with the State Department. If so, the administration should say so and make sure Insley and his firm are no longer receiving taxpayer dollars for his highly objectionable activities.
Indeed.
I wonder what these creeps - who also attended the conference - thought of Mr. Insley's speech.
By the way, I understand that several bloggers, including Jonathan Tobin (whom I quoted above) have been threatened by Insley.
Sickening video: Abu Mazen and Emir of Qatar shake hands with Neturei Karta's Hirsh
In earlier posts I mentioned the 'International Conference for the Defense of Jerusalem' which is taking place in Qatar. In this video, you will see Neturei Karta's Rabbi Meir Hirsh shaking hands with Abu Mazen and with the Emir of Qatar.
I am sure that many of you have heard of the ongoing unrest in the Jerusalem corridor city of Beit Shemesh between certain anti-Zionist Haredim and parts of the National Religious community.
I don't want to get into a discussion of who is right and who is wrong - assuming that the dispute is a real one. That's not the topic of this blog. You can write me whatever you want about it by email, but I will delete comments that are going in that direction. Rather, I want to share with you an interesting theory regarding who might be behind the unrest.
Many think of Judaism as a single religion, but it has as many denominations and subsets as Christianity does. Orthodox Judaism equally breaks down into countless subsets. Most of the problems in Jerusalem concern 19th century immigrant sects which never reconciled themselves to the creation of the State of Israel, and have in some cases made common cause with Islam.
The Neturei Karta, who have been denounced by every mainstream Orthodox denomination, were friendly with the Ayatollah Khomeini and are friendly with Ahmadinejad. They held prayer vigils for Arafat and took blood money from his kleptocracy. They are best thought of as the Jewish version of the Westboro Baptist Church which pickets military funerals, complete with gloating messages after terrorist attacks and assaults on other Orthodox Jews.
One Neturei Karta leader who was famously photographed in a liplock with Iranian genocidal thug Ahmadinejad also met with Neo-Nazis and his children were expelled from school after being taught to cheer terrorist attacks. Other Neturei Karta leaders have met with Farrakhan and Hamas terrorists. But while some NK leaders forbid traveling to Israel, much of the movement (which despite its small size has its own splinter groups) is still embedded in Jerusalem. There it has engaged in a variety of violent incidents against Jewish businesses and residents. And like their Muslim brethren, their feelings for women mirror their feelings for Zionism.
Leftist media describe Neturei Karta leaders as "Anti-Zionist Jews" when they're doing a story on their participation in an Anti-Israel protest in New York or London, but when they attack bookstores or girls' schools in Israel then they are suddenly "Ultra-Orthodox Extremists" even when the people they are attacking are Orthodox Jews.
The Neturei Karta assaults on Jews and their support for terrorists have been a problem for some time. And the outrageous prayer vigils for Arafat and the harassment of Jewish schoolgirls are all despicable and depraved behavior by a corrupt cult which has engaged in kidnapping and child abuse. The NK are not the only ones involved, but they are at the heart of the problem.
However the Soros funded left is exploiting the anti-social behavior of their fellow anti-Zionists to demonize Israel, build a protest movement for their own purposes and launch a wider campaign against religious Jews. Their technique involves conflating violent incidents with local customs to create the appearance of a larger social problem. Thus an assault on a bus is equated to religious soldiers leaving a musical performance which violated their religious sensibilities.
Frankly, I'm not sure I buy into this. While Neturei Karta and Toldoth Aharon (the sect that is largely behind the Beit Shemesh demonstrations) are both anti-Zionist, they are not identical. Toldoth Aharon does not do things like travel to Iran to kiss Ahmadinejad. In fact, most of them refuse to leave Israel at all and have done so for seven or eight generations. I seriously doubt that Toldoth Aharon would knowingly take any kind of support from Soros. Of course, it is possible that Neturei Karta is egging Toldoth Aharon on (they both live in the same neighborhood in Jerusalem).
Boo hoo! Neturei Karta loses funding from 'Palestinian Authority'
The daughter of the 'Palestinian Authority's 'Minister of Jewish Affairs' was married last week in Jerusalem. The wedding was held in a private home at 7:00 am rather than in a banquet hall. Apparently, the 'Palestinian Authority' is no longer funding Neturei Karta.
As proof of their strong stand against the State of Israel's existence, they made sure to mention in the invitations that the event would be held at "the holy city of Jerusalem, Palestine." Accordingly, the time of the wedding ceremony was mentioned in Central European Time.
Ahead of the wedding day, the family learned that the wedding had sparked a great deal of interest in the haredi sector, especially in light of the fact that the bride observes strict modesty rules. Therefore, it was decided to move up the wedding ceremony from 2 pm to 7 am, and hold it in a private house outside the neighborhood.
The modest bride wore a white dress covered with a black coat. According to one of Hirsch's neighbors, before they decided to marry her husband looked at her just once during a conversation which last several minutes.
"I'm sure it was enough, as she's a beautiful girl," he noted.
The joyous occasion was celebrated in the evening, in a modest meal at the home of the bride's parents. The guests were greeted by a Palestinian flag decorated with the word "Welcome" in Arabic and English.
Sunday was celebrated as 'al-Quds' (Jerusalem) day in London. The featured speaker was Tony Blair's Muslim convert sister-in-law, Lauren Booth, who called on Jordan, Egypt and Lebanon to 'liberate' Jerusalem. And no, these people aren't looking for a 'two-state solution.'
I'm beginning to think it's time for Jews to stop visiting London. I say that as someone who probably changes planes there 2-3 times per year (often including a trip into the city). I'm seriously having second thoughts about it. While Trafalgar Square wasn't full on Sunday, that doesn't make London any less hostile to us.
As Israelis bury their dead, Jew haters protest in London
An hour before the Sabbath, the Jew haters gathered outside the Israeli embassy in London to make their feelings known while Israeli Jews buried their dead.
Let's go to the videotape.
These people were also there (who makes the Sabbath for them or don't they bother anymore).
I am an Orthodox Jew - some would even call me 'ultra-Orthodox.' Born in Boston, I was a corporate and securities attorney in New York City for seven years before making aliya to Israel in 1991 (I don't look it but I really am that old :-). I have been happily married to the same woman for thirty-five years, and we have eight children (bli ayin hara) ranging in age from 13 to 33 years and nine grandchildren. Four of our children are married! Before I started blogging I was a heavy contributor on a number of email lists and ran an email list called the Matzav from 2000-2004. You can contact me at: IsraelMatzav at gmail dot com