Work stopped on Golden Rose Hotel Project
Some of you may recall the story last week about the
Golden Rose Hotel project. I am pleased to tell you that the project has been
stopped.
Since the article appeared six days ago, it has been discussed both in the international and Ukrainian media. It has been translated into Ukrainian and Russian, the two main languages of Ukraine, and a number of prominent commentators and public figures there have spoken out in support of the article (in contrast to some of the readers both on Ukrainian and Western websites who have left vicious anti-Semitic comments and comments amounting to Holocaust denial).
Yesterday, Anna Herman, the spokesperson and chief advisor to Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych in the capital Kiev, spoke with the mayor of Lviv, Andriy Sadovy, and ordered that works on and abutting the Golden Rose complex in Lviv be stopped.
Herman said: “This historic place in Lviv has to be preserved. This place is important for the memory of hundreds of thousands of Jews murdered in the Lviv region. Even the Communists never built over this place. Or should we be more barbaric than them?”
In response, the mayor of Lviv assured the authorities in Kiev yesterday that works in and around the former Golden Rose complex were now being stopped.
Occasionally, there is is justice in this world.
Labels: anti-Semitism, Holocaust denial, Lemberg, Lviv, Lvov, Ukraine
Holocaust denial alive and well in Ukraine
Tom Gross reports on the destruction of the ancient synagogue of Lemberg, Austria (later Lvov, Poland) to make way for a hotel in Lviv, Ukraine (yes, they're all the same place).
The synagogue was part of a UNESCO heritage site where thousands of Jews were murdered between 1941-44, but
no one cares.
Last week I watched as bulldozers began to demolish the adjacent remnants of what was once one of Europe's most beautiful synagogue complexes, the 16th-century Golden Rose in Lviv. Most of the rest of the synagogue was burned down, with Jews inside, by the Nazis in 1941.
During the war, 42 other synagogues were destroyed in Lviv, which from the middle ages to the 20th century was known by its Austrian (and Yiddish) name, Lemberg, and then called Lvov after the Soviets annexed it in 1945. The remnants of the Golden Rose are one of the few remaining vestiges of Jewish existence in Lviv, the majority of whose residents, in 1940, were Jewish.
It is not only morally wrong for bulldozers to drill through the last traces of this vibrant past without first giving the handful of remaining Jews here a chance to restore this site, or turn it into a place of memorial. It is legally wrong, too. Ukraine's own laws are designed to preserve such historic sites.
The Ukrainian authorities are not the only ones at fault. Where is the UN cultural organisation, Unesco? The synagogue ruins were designated part of a Unesco world heritage site in 1998.
And where is the European football body, Uefa? The Ukrainians are planning to build a hotel on the site to host next year's European football championships, the world's third most-watched sporting event, which they are co-hosting with Poland. So much for Uefa's much-hyped campaign to "kick racism out of football". (In addition to there being residual antisemitism in Ukraine, the authorities seem to be motivated by cultural and historical crassness and illiteracy and denial of the past, as well as real-estate greed.)
During the Holocaust, 420,000 Jews, including more than 100,000 children, were murdered in Lviv and its environs, more than in almost any other city in Europe. The killing was so efficient that the Nazis organised transports of Romanian and Hungarian Jews to be brought here to be killed once they were done killing the Polish and Ukrainian Jews. There were almost no survivors.
Yet you will hardly find any reference to this in the official guide books or in the museums of Lviv. There is no monument to the murdered Jews in Lviv's old town.
No one should be surprised by this.
UNESCO,
UEFA (including its parent body,
FIFA) and the
Ukrainian government all have long and painful records of anti-Semitism. And surely you don't think they're going to admit that they did anything wrong in the Holocaust, do you? I mean, the Ukrainians were 'victims' just like the Austrians and the Poles.
Read the whole thing. The new hotel is pictured below.
Labels: anti-Semitism, Holocaust denial, Lemberg, Lviv, Lvov, Ukraine
Some of you may recall the story last week about the Golden Rose Hotel project. I am pleased to tell you that the project has been stopped. 
